Skip to content

NSF Nominee “Did Not Do Enough to Stand Up for Science”

As noted, the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee was scheduled to vote on the nomination of Jim O’Neill to serve as the director of NSF this morning. However, O’Neill’s nomination was pulled before the vote.

During this morning’s committee meeting, Chairman Bill Cassidy (R-LA) noted that O’Neill “did not do enough to stand up for science” while he served as the acting director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and did not push back against irresponsible statements made by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert Kennedy, Jr.  He added that several members of the HELP Committee had reservations about the nomination.

The director’s position at NSF remains vacant.

NSF & FDA Nominee Votes Pulled

The White House pulled the nomination of Heidi Overton to be Food and Drug Administration commissioner hours before she was scheduled to receive a vote today at the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee. HELP Chair Bill Cassidy said on X late Tuesday that the White House abandoned “a viable confirmation path” for Overton, who he said had the votes to advance.

Chair Cassidy also announced this morning that NSF Director Nominee Jim O’Neill would not be considered for a vote today, as previously planned.

Committee to Vote on NSF Director Nomination

The Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee has scheduled a vote on the nomination of James O’Neill to head the National Science Foundation (NSF) for November 18.  O’Neill was nominated for the top post at NSF after the resignation of the last director “Panch” Panchanathan.

O’Neill has previously served at the Department of Health and Human Services.  He was nominated for the NSF post earlier this year and there were questions about whether the  leadership of the HELP Committee would move his nomination forward before the end of this Congress.

The announcement about the vote was released earlier today.

Hegseth Impeachment Effort Blocked

House Republicans this evening blocked an effort to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, in a 211 to 204 vote. The impeachment process was spearheaded by Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY), who was the only Republican to vote with Democrats.

The vote was to impeach Hegseth on eighth separate charges, which included violating the Constitution by starting the war in Iran without congressional authorization. Republican leaders worried that low Republican attendance would allow the impeachment effort to move forward. In the end, 11 Democratic members also missed the roll call vote.

Democrats could still try to impeach Hegseth next year when they control Congress.

Lame-Duck Session Begins

Congress has entered its five-week “lame-duck session,” the period between November elections and the beginning of a new Congress in January.

Lame-duck legislative priorities:

Appropriators are hoping to wrap up the final fiscal year 2027 spending bills. Funding talks are on a tight timeline before the December 11 deadline when stopgap funding is set to expire. No one wants another government shutdown, but some Democrats, pointing to their significant victories and upcoming leverage, say they should focus on ending the Iran war before agreeing to any final funding deal.

Meanwhile, Republicans are hoping to make progress on President Trump’s $1.5 trillion defense spending request, a tall order considering the limited time frame. Republicans are in their final stretch of opportunity to push through priority bills before they lose their majority, including talks of a filibuster-proof reconciliation bill which would boost defense spending. However, with only five weeks of session left, a reconciliation bill would be tough to pass through both chambers, especially as Republican attendance is critical. Republicans who have just lost reelection bids, were pushed out by Trump, or are retiring may have less motivation to return for the lame-duck session.

Too Close to Call: 

Votes continue to be counted in several consequential races across the country. In Mississippi, the Democratic Senate nominee Scott Colom is holding a narrow lead over incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith. In Alaska, Democrat Mary Peltola holds a narrow lead over Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. Winning both seats would bump the Democratic majority up to 56 seats.

New Members Arrive:

Incoming members are arriving for orientation, and leadership elections are beginning in both parties. Republicans hold their leadership elections tomorrow. Speaker Mike Johnson has said he won’t run for House minority leader, clearing the path for a fight between Majority Leader Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan.

Democratic leadership elections are scheduled for next week. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries is expected to run for House speaker, while Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer is expected to be elected as Senate majority leader. There have been calls for new leadership, but so far no clear opponents have emerged.

Major White House Shake-Up:

In the aftermath of the midterms, President Trump has ousted his chief of staff, Susie Wiles, and replaced her with Stephen Miller. Miller is best known for orchestrating the administration’s immigration and deportation program.

Agency Departures:

High-profile resignations are expected to ramp up as heads of agencies face the prospect of intense oversight investigations from Congress. Harmeet Dhillon, chief of the Justice Department’s civil rights division, resigned last Thursday. Dhillon was a key player in the Trump administration’s attacks on higher education, as she opened several investigations and lawsuits against universities over admissions practices, free-speech policies, and anti-DEI initiatives.

What we’re reading this week:

What a Democratic Congress Could Mean for Science – The New York Times