University of Washington
Administrative Policy Statements
Rev/Feb 1997 32.3

Table of Contents
      

A Guide for Determination of Employee
Versus Independent Contractor Status

(Approved by the Executive Vice President by authority of Executive Order No. 5)


1.   General Overview

The characterization of individuals as independent contractors or employees has important tax and non-tax consequences to both the University and the individual. It is generally more advantageous to federal and state government to have an individual classified as an employee. When faced with a characterization issue during the course of an employment tax audit, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) will almost always treat individuals as employees, absent a reasonable basis for classification as an independent contractor on the part of the employer. Misclassification of an individual can be very expensive to the University (or to persons in positions of responsibility), so it is essential that proper characterization of an individual be determined before any payments are made to an individual for services performed.

2.   General Tax Consequences

Classification of an individual as an employee or an independent contractor has significant tax consequences for the University, the individual, and the government.

a.   Employee

If an individual is classified as an employee, the University is required to withhold income and Social Security (FICA) taxes on the wages paid to the employee. The University is required to pay a matching FICA tax. In addition, classification as an employee may require that the employee be included in pension plans and other fringe benefit programs, which would not be applicable if classified as an independent contractor. The University must file an IRS Form 941 on a quarterly basis to report and remit taxes withheld on wages paid, and must prepare and file an IRS Form W-2 for each employee at the end of each calendar year. Since the burden is on the employee to file an income tax return and obtain refunds, compliance problems for the government are accordingly diminished.

b.   Independent Contractor

If an individual is classified as an independent contractor, payments made for services are not subject to income tax withholding, FICA, or Federal Unemployment Tax (FUTA). Instead, the independent contractor is liable for estimated tax payments and for self-employment tax (SECA). The University is responsible for preparing and filing an IRS Form 1099 for payments made to each independent contractor at the end of each calendar year whenever the cumulative amount of payments to the independent contractor is $600 or more. Since there is no withholding requirement for payments to independent contractors, compliance problems for the government are increased dramatically.

c.   Liabilities for Misclassification of an Employee as an Independent Contractor

If the University classifies an individual as an independent contractor instead of an employee, and cannot demonstrate a reasonable basis for the classification, the IRS can hold the University (or specific persons) liable for several different fines or penalties-ranging in severity from 1.5%–3% of wages paid, to a criminal penalty of $100,000 and/or five years in prison if any person is deemed to have willfully or intentionally misclassified an individual in order to evade employment taxes. The University may also be required to pay the full amount (both the employee's and employer's share) of contributions due to applicable pension plans retroactive to the date the individual was first paid as an independent contractor instead of an employee.

3.   Definitions and Guidelines for Determining Classification

a.   Employee Definition

An individual who performs personal services for the University where the University has the right to control and direct the individual who performs the services, not only as to the result to be accomplished, but also as to the details and means by which that result is to be accomplished. It is not necessary that the University actually direct or control the manner in which the services are performed; it is sufficient to establish an employee-employer relationship that the University has the right to do so.

b.   Employer Definition

The University—when it has a relationship with an individual performing services for its benefit, and where the University has the right to subject the individual to its will, and control not only what shall be done but how it shall be done.

c.   Independent Contractor Definition

An individual who performs personal services for the University where the University has the right to specify the result to be accomplished by the work, but not the means and methods by which the result is to be accomplished.

d.   Guidelines for Determining Classification

 1) The IRS "Common Law" Test—As indicated in the definitions above, the most important consideration in determining whether an employer-employee relationship exists with an individual is whether the University has the right to instruct and control the individual with respect to both the results and the details of the work that is to be performed. The IRS has developed a 20-factor "common law" test which it uses to determine whether sufficient control and supervision exist to warrant an employee classification of an individual. However, no definitive combination of factors has been established by the IRS with which a concrete determination can be made. The factors are simply indicators which may be used to assist in determining the degree of control that may be exercised over the individual, and thus the most appropriate classification for the individual.

 2) Classification Checklist and Criteria—In an effort to simplify the determination process for the most common situations in which the University seeks to obtain the services of individuals, the Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist form has been developed for use by University departments. The checklist may be used in evaluating whether an individual should be classified as an employee or an independent contractor and is a required attachment to any purchase requisition (submitted via the Purchasing/Accounts Payable System (PAS) online) to obtain the services of an independent contractor. The checklist is self-explanatory.

Included with the checklist are classification criteria for classifying an individual as an independent contractor based on the 20 factors used by the IRS. These classification criteria are provided as additional guidance to departments for determining an individual's classification and are not required to be completed by the department.

4.   Responsibility for Determining the Classification

a.   Department Responsibility

The primary responsibility for determining the classification of an individual as an employee or an independent contractor rests with the department obtaining the personal services. The department must make the initial determination by completing the Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist form. If the department determines that an individual should be classified as an employee, the individual must be placed on and paid through the University Payroll system as outlined in Section 5 of this policy statement. If the department determines that an individual may appropriately be classified as an independent contractor, the individual may be paid through the PAS system as outlined in Section 6 of this policy statement.

b.   The Purchasing Department (Buyer) Responsibility

Upon receipt of a purchase requisition to acquire the services of an individual as an independent contractor, the assigned buyer will first confirm that the individual has been appropriately classified as an independent contractor before proceeding to obtain the services. In confirming independent contractor status, the buyer will review the description of services contained in the purchase requisition and the attached Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist form submitted by the department, and will also access the Higher Education Payroll/Personnel System (HEPPS) to determine if the individual has ever been paid as an employee of the University by any department. In questionable cases, the buyer will discuss the determination with the requesting department to gain consensus on the appropriate classification. Additional documentation or evidence may be requested to support the final determination. The buyer may seek the counsel of his or her supervisor, the Director of the Purchasing Department, or the Director of the Payables and Accounting Operations Office, as necessary. In extreme cases where classification as an independent contractor is still questionable after thorough review, and the department or individual resists appointment as an employee of the University, an IRS Form SS-8 will be submitted to obtain an official determination from the IRS before acquiring the services of the individual.

5.   Payment of Individuals Classified as Employees

a.   Examples of Individuals Generally Classified as Employees

The examples below are not all-inclusive. Departments should determine an individual's classification by using the Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist as a guide whenever doubt exists as to the proper classification of an individual providing services to the University.

Employee examples include:

  • Contract-Classified Staff
  • Credit or Noncredit Primary Course Instructors
  • Faculty
  • Hourly Employees
  • Medical Residents
  • Professional Staff
  • Research Assistants
  • Student Helpers
  • Teaching Assistants
  • WPRB–Classified Staff

b.   Appointment Forms and Procedures

Employees are paid through the HEPPS system. Employees are placed on the HEPPS system when the hiring department completes a Personnel Action (PAF) form, an IRS Withholding Allowances Form W-4, and an Immigration and Naturalization Service Employment Eligibility Verification Form I-9, and submits them to the Payroll Office.

6.   Payment of Individuals Classified as Independent Contractors

a.   Examples of Individuals Generally Classified as Independent Contractors

The examples below are not all-inclusive and may not be suitable depending upon circumstances and the amount of control the University has over the individual performing the services. Departments must complete the Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist form to support any determination that an individual is to be classified as an independent contractor.

Independent contractor examples include the following when the individuals provide services to other entities or the general public in addition to the University:

  • Artists
  • Consultants
  • Guest Lecturers and Seminar Leaders (occasional service and not primary course instructors)
  • Lawyers
  • Musicians
  • Public Stenographers
  • Veterinarians

b.   Appointment Forms and Procedures

Independent contractors are paid through the PAS system. Departments acquiring the services of an independent contractor must complete a purchase requisition (submitted via the PAS online system) and an Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist form as an attachment to be submitted to the Purchasing Department. Note: It is recommended that the purchase requisition be submitted prior to making a commitment with the individual for the performance of services. Additionally, even if the department is submitting a "confirming" purchase requisition, an Employee Versus Independent Contractor Classification Checklist must still be submitted as an attachment. Except for payment of honoraria to a guest lecturer or payment to an artist or musician where it is customary to pay the individual immediately after a performance, the independent contractor is required to submit an invoice to the Accounts Payable Office Office, Box 351130, subsequent to performance of the services.

For payment of honoraria to guest lecturers or payment to artists and musicians, an Invoice Voucher/Receiving Report form may be submitted as an attachment to the purchase requisition (or sent directly to the Accounts Payable Office, Box 351130) so that the payment may be prepared for presentation to the individual immediately after the performance of service.

 1) Independent Contractors Who Are United States Citizens or Resident Aliens for Tax Purposes—For an independent contractor who is a United States citizen or resident alien for tax purposes, a Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) and a permanent mailing address are required prior to making payments to an independent contractor, since the University must accumulate payments for possible information return reporting on a Miscellaneous Income, IRS form 1099. The TIN for an individual is their Social Security number. Note: The preferred method of obtaining the TIN and address is by having the independent contractor complete a Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification, IRS form W-9, and submitting it with the invoice or Invoice Voucher/Receiving Report to obtain payment. The Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification, IRS form W-9, may be obtained from the Accounting Operation Office, 206–543–8414, or from the IRS directly.

 2) Independent Contractors Who Are Nonresident Aliens for Tax Purposes—For independent contractors who are nonresident aliens for tax purposes, see Administrative Policy Statement 32.4.

Top of Page