The Dawn of Conservation Diplomacy

U.S.-Canadian Wildlife Protection Treaties in the Progressive Era

Kurkpatrick Dorsey
Foreword by William Cronon

  • Published: 1998. Paperback 2010
  • Subject Listing: History / Environmental History; Environmental Studies
  • Bibliographic information: 328 pp., 24 bandw photos
  • Territorial rights: World Rights
  • Series: Weyerhaeuser Environmental Books
  • Contents

In the first decades of the twentieth century, fish in the Great Lakes and Puget Sound, seals in the North Pacific, and birds across North America faced a common threat: over harvesting that threatened extinction for many species. Progressive era conservationists saw a need for government intervention to protect threatened animals. And because so many species migrated across international political boundaries, their protectors saw the necessity of international conservation agreements. In The Dawn of Conservation Diplomacy, Kurkpatrick Dorsey examines the first three comprehensive wildlife conservation treaties in history, all between the United States and Canada: the Inland Fisheries Treaty of 1908, the North Pacific Fur Seal Convention of 1911, and the Migratory Bird Treaty of 1916.

In his highly readable text, Dorsey argues that successful conservation treaties came only after conservationists learned to marshal scientific evidence, public sentiment, and economic incentives in their campaigns for protective legislation. The first treaty, intended to rescue the overfished boundary waters, failed to gain the necessary support and never became law. Despite scientific evidence of the need for conservation, politicians, and the general public were unable to counter the vocal opposition of fishermen across the continent. A few years later, conservationists successfully rallied popular sympathy for fur seals threatened with slaughter and the North Pacific Fur Seal Convention was adopted. By the time of the Migratory Bird Treaty of 1916, the importance of aesthetic appeal was clear: North American citizens were joining chapters of the Audubon Society in efforts to protect beautiful songbirds. Conservationists also presented economic evidence to support their efforts as they argued that threatened bird species provided invaluable service to farmers.

Dorsey recounts the story of each of these early treaties, examining the scientific research that provided the basis for each effort, acknowledging the complexity of the issues, and presenting the personalities behind the politics. He argues that these decades-old treaties both directly affect us today and offer lessons for future conservation efforts.
Kurkpatrick Dorsey is associate professor of history at the University of New Hampshire.

"Dorsey's superb book connects ecological science, economic interest groups, politics at the local, national, and international level, and the quirks and achievements of colorful advocates. Here is a model for a new and important field of international history."
-Gaddis Smith, Yale University

"Kurkpatrick Dorsey understands how politics deeply affects diplomacy and how public opinion shapes conservation policies. So many issues are similar to those which frustrate Canadian and American negotiators today. The Dawn of Conservation Diplomacy is excellent history which illuminates both past and present."
-John English, University of Waterloo and former Member of Parliament, Canadian House of Commons

"This is a pioneering work that opens fresh, important perspectives on Americans by revealing their views on preserving (and exploiting) their natural environment, their introduction to science into policy decisions, their too-often cynical approach to relations with Canada, and their political genius for 'the art of the deal.' And it is all superbly done."
-Walter LaFeber, Cornell University

"A well-researched and well-written account of an important early chapter in international wildlife preservation of interest not only to environmental historians but anyone interested in the contemporary problems of international cooperation for environmental preservation."
-Tom Dunlap, author of Saving America's Wildlife

Foreword by William Cronon
Introduction: The Intersection of Diplomacy and Conservation
A Problem of Scale, 1892-1897
The Jordon Rules, 1898-1909
The One That Got Away, 1909-1914
Conflict in the Bering Sea, 1886-1899
Conciliation and Conservation, 1900-1912
Of Mallards and Men, 1883-1913
Coordinating Science, Diplomacy, and Public Relations, 1913-1916
Protecting the National Interest, 1916-1920
Epilogue: Implications of the Progressive Treaties